Honest Amish Beard Balm Vs Heavy Duty: Which Product Is Better?

Last Updated on January 6, 2022 by Sam

There is a lot of debate about which beard balm offers the best performance for your needs. Some say that a heavy duty product like Honest Amish Beard Balm will provide better value, while others are more concerned with smell and aesthetics.

The “difference between honest amish classic and premium” is a question that has been asked many times before. This article will help you decide which product is better.

Honest Amish distinguishes out among the crowded industry of beard grooming products. The firm from western Pennsylvania has a reputation for producing high-quality items produced from natural components. Although the Honest Amish does not have a large product line, they do carry two beard balms: normal and heavy duty. Which product do you think you should buy?

Honest Amish’s beard and bath products are handmade and 100 percent organic, including two top-of-the-line beard balms. They have high-quality components and provide excellent results. For a short beard, we like their normal balm. Longer, wilder beards, on the other hand, need the Heavy Duty product.

Let’s take a look at the history and purpose of a beardsman’s favorite business. Then we’ll compare Honest Amish Beard Balm to Honest Amish Heavy Duty on a point-by-point basis. 

From the Farmer’s Market to Amazon’s Top Shelf

Despite its widespread use in the men’s grooming industry, Honest Amish had a humble beginning. 

To begin, we should point out that this product does not seem to be made by the Amish. The name symbolizes the company’s all-natural approach as well as the fact that it was founded in Pennsylvania Dutch area. Plus, anybody who has visited the area or watched the Harrison Ford film Witness knows that the Amish can wear a major beard.


Jason Wolfgang Kushner’s passion endeavor is the Honest Amish. He started making up his beard and bath products and selling them at farmer’s markets in the early 2010s. In January 2012, he went to Etsy, where he was able to distribute his wares all over the country.

This firm, as you may have observed, has been in the beard game for quite some time. The men’s grooming industry was much smaller and less lucrative in 2011. They formed as Honest Industries in 2014. Other toiletry brands have been acquired by this company.

According to Mr. Kushner, Honest Amish is now the “manufacturer of the #1 best selling aftershave/grooming aid on Amazon.” In Pennsylvania, New Jersey, France, and the Netherlands, there are Honest Amish Beard Care locations. Their goods are available for purchase both online and in Walmart.

The Reputation of the Honest Amish

Honest Amish has gone from an incredibly locavore venture to a worldwide fixture in the decade since it first appeared on the scene. The company’s commitment to handmade goods hasn’t altered.

Honest Amish claims on their website that all of their items are handcrafted. Natural carrier oils are used in all of their salves and oils, and locally obtained beeswax is used in all of their balms and waxes. They even manufacture their own licorice!

In a nutshell, the Honest Amish brand is well-known. And they, as far as we can tell, walk the walk. A look at their goods reveals a distinct absence of manufactured substances and artificial fragrances. It’s easy to understand why this firm has such a strong position in men’s grooming when you combine all-natural manufacturing with a reasonable pricing point.

That said, a one-of-a-kind, organic product is only valuable if it works. The Honest Amish have a reputation for producing high-quality beard products. So, let’s get down to business with its beard balm.

What is Beard Balm, exactly?

Beard balm is a leave-in conditioner designed specifically for your facial hair. It’s usually made out of a natural wax that’s been churned with shea or cocoa butter and a variety of carrier oils. It’s similar to dry beard oil in this way. Some stores even advertise it as such.

Beard balm has a lot of the same moisturizing and restorative properties as beard oil. It moisturizes your face by brushing it through your facial hair and onto your skin. It also softens and repairs split ends in that uncontrolled thicket on your face.

Finally, beard balm enhances the appearance and scent of your facial hair. It adds textural richness to your beard as well as a hint of gloss. Essential oils and various perfumes are often present. Musk, citrus, woodland, herbs, or any other delightful frisson will linger on your face. 

Beard balm isn’t technically a styling product. It will keep your beard in place to some degree, but that isn’t its major purpose. You might think of it as a kind of taming product.

Even yet, some beard balms work better than others, bringing us back to Honest Amish.

Beard Balms from the Amish — What’s in Them, Anyway?

The components are the first step. You can create a terrible beard balm with high-quality components, but you’re almost certain to make a horrible balm with low-quality ones.

Honest Amish Beard Balms - What’s in Them

When we open the hood of Honest Amish’s beard balms, what do we find?

“We never use man-made chemicals, scents, petroleum by-products, or man-made preservatives, and we never package or containerize our items in plastics,” the firm proudly declares.

This seems to be the case, and we are all concerned about maintaining a high level of output. We’ve cautioned you before about the dangers of petroleum-based cosmetics, which do nothing to moisturise your skin. Inorganic compounds with names ending in -ide and -ate are also found in several perfectly fine beard products. You merely squint and pray that they don’t injure your face or beard.

Honest Amish goods don’t include any of these synthetics. We’ve replaced them with some high-quality waxes, butters, and oils.

Here’s a complete list of Honest Amish’s basic Beard Balm’s base components (excluding aromatics):

Waxes Emulsifying Wax, Candelilla Wax, Organic Yellow Beeswax
Butters Organic Cocoa Butter, Kokum Butter, and Organic Shea Nut Butter, White Refined
Oils that act as a carrier Extra Virgin Organic Pumpkin Seed Oil, Apricot Kernel Oil, Avocado Oil, Extra Virgin RBD Organic Olive Oil, Sweet Almond Oil, RBD Organic Coconut Oil, Virgin Organic Argan Nut Oil

The bottom line is that all of these substances are beneficial to your skin and hair.

The mix of waxes is of particular importance to us. Candelilla and beeswax have emollient characteristics, which means they will absorb moisture into your face and beard. Meanwhile, emulsifying wax holds everything together. We’re interested to see what these balms can achieve in conjunction with the murderers’ row of hydrating butters and sumptuous oils.

Furthermore, essential oils, not synthetic perfumes, provide the olfactory component of Honest Amish beard balms.

What’s the Difference Between These Two Balms?

Honest Amish’s Heavy Duty Beard Balm has a harder consistency than the basic product, which is somewhat predictable. Heavy Duty, according to the firm, “provides additional control and softness.”

The lack of Castor Oil may be seen in the Heavy Duty variation’s component list. All of the other carriers are present, which we agree of wholeheartedly. Castor oil is a good emollient, yet it’s the least expensive of Honest Amish’s carriers. The beardsman is the ultimate benefactor if the corporation has chosen to thicken this product by omitting it.

The key structural difference between Honest Amish Beard Balm and Heavy Duty seems to be this. Except for Castor Oil, the other components stay the same. In proportion, Heavy Duty digs deeper into the wax. 

The essential oils in the two balms are also distinct, resulting in dramatically different scents.


Given that Honest Amish has a side business in organic licorice, we shouldn’t be shocked to learn that anise is used in its Beard Balm. A bright, fun blend of star anise, lavender, cinnamon, grapefruit, cedarwood, and clove makes up the basic balm.

With a pleasant farm and woodland undertone, the overall impression is candied and refreshing. The licorice and citrus come through initially in the nose, but they fade swiftly. The base scents of wood and spice linger, giving your facial hair a fittingly idyllic farm-stand scent.

The aroma of Heavy Duty is more difficult to grasp. Honest Amish opted to considerably reduce the fragrance of its thicker balm for whatever reason. Honest Amish argues that since this product appeals to men with longer beards, they will use more of the balm.

Regardless, the scent of Heavy Duty Beard Balm is rose petal, clove, and wood. These tones, on the other hand, are more restrained. The natural oil and butter scents come through loud and clear. Overall, it’s a lovely, unobtrusive scent that you’ll like having with you all day.

If you’re looking for a genuine Amish beard balm, go for Honest Amish Beard Balm.  If you’re looking for a heavy-duty beard balm, go for Honest Amish Heavy Duty Beard Balm. 
You’re looking for a fun, lively combination of candy, fruit, and farmhouse. You want a more reserved, traditional floral balm that lingers under the surface.


The Heavy Duty balm is substantially thicker than the normal balm, as we’ve previously established. That’s understandable. It’s worth mentioning, however, that Honest Amish’s standard beard balm is a lot softer than other beard balms. There seems to be a greater presence of butter. When you add in the presence of various carrier oils, you end up with a balm that resembles a thick cream.

Honest Amish Heavy Duty Beard Balm, on the other hand, has a consistency similar to putty or pomade. To create a significant dent in this product, you’ll need to use considerable force. Heavy Duty, on the other hand, has a luscious, wet flavor. It’s just more durable and waxy.

If you’re looking for a genuine Amish beard balm, go for Honest Amish Beard Balm.  If you’re looking for a heavy-duty beard balm, go for Honest Amish Heavy Duty Beard Balm. 
You want to use your hands to apply your balm fast and easily. With a robust boar- or horse-hair beard brush, you like to work your product in.

Hold and Application

The Honest Amish Beard Balm mixes beautifully. Without any resistance, you may rapidly pull a little dollop from the container and distribute it over your palms. It coats like a beard butter rather than a balm in many aspects. The regular balm, when warmed and combined, glides easily and pleasantly over your facial hair.

Beard Balm Application and Hold

A little of this beard balm goes a long way, thanks to its high butter and oil content. If you have a shorter beard, we suggest starting slowly. You may easily apply extra if your beard seems under-conditioned after application.

The regular balm gives your beard some excellent weight and structure, but it doesn’t provide much grip. You’ll want to use the Heavy Duty Beard Balm for this.

It requires a lot more effort and friction to extract and emulsify this balm. It also takes a bit longer to get it through your beard. A nice beard brush proved to be really beneficial. Nonetheless, the end effect is well worth the effort. With a considerably firmer grip, you receive all of the natural-looking texture of the lighter balm.

For many guys, the Honest Amish Heavy Duty Beard Balm will enough as a styling product on its own.

If you’re looking for a genuine Amish beard balm, go for Honest Amish Beard Balm.  If you’re looking for a heavy-duty beard balm, go for Honest Amish Heavy Duty Beard Balm. 
You want to add texture and gloss to your short or naturally relaxed beard. An unkempt beard requires more active management.

Effect on the Whole

Both Honest Amish Beard Balm and Heavy Duty Beard Balm provide comparable – and equally acceptable – results in most cases.

Both goods had a powerfully textured, well-hydrated texture. Our facial hair caught the light beautifully. Despite this, there was no oily sheen that certain balms sometimes leave behind. Either the original beard balm or its heavy-duty equivalent is ideal for making your beard seem thick and healthy.

Even yet, each balm has a somewhat distinct impact. The lighter product, as you would expect, makes your hair seem less controlled and more free-flowing. Many beardsmen will adore it, or they may tone it down with a little combing.

The Heavy Duty appearance is significantly more streamlined and… well, heavier. If you have a straw broom beard, we’re guessing that’s exactly what the barber requested. It all depends on the amount of facial hair you have and how you want it to appear.

If you’re looking for a genuine Amish beard balm, go for Honest Amish Beard Balm.  If you’re looking for a heavy-duty beard balm, go for Honest Amish Heavy Duty Beard Balm. 
You’re going for a natural, light appearance with just enough thickness. You’ve got a lot of hair to condition, and you’d want to have some control over the process.

How to Apply Genuine Amish Beard Balm

Beard balm is usually applied to your face after a shower or face wash. Your beard should be clean and your pores should be open. However, make sure your facial hair is completely dry before applying.

Tips for Applying Honest Amish Beard Balm

It will be easier to get nice, comprehensive coverage if you have a mirror nearby.

We like to brush beard balm straight into our beards, ensuring that the bristles reach the flesh underneath. Some men like to apply beard balm by hand. To do so, take two fingers and swipe some out of the tin, then spread it over both of your hands. Then rub it into your skin and facial hair.

Try to keep the quantity of beard balm you use to a minimum, no matter how you apply it. You want your beard to seem healthy and full of life. It will seem greasy if you use too much balm. Also, even if you apply your beard balm by hand, we suggest brushing and combing your beard shortly thereafter.

If your beard seems wild and unruly after using the balm, you may shape it with a styling tool. In fact, Honest Amish also sells beard wax.

Beard Balms That Are Comparable

Honest Amish’s beard balms are top-selling goods on Amazon and in shops for a reason. These items are almost unequaled for their inexpensive price. They are 100 percent organic, according to our investigation. Your facial hair will have a beautiful new look, and the aromas will be on the verge of becoming magnificent.

Nonetheless, there are alternatives, some of which are equivalent.

Cremo Styling Beard Balm could be right for you if you’re seeking for a lighter balm with a lot of conditioning power at a reasonable price. As we saw in a previous piece, the Cremo brand always manages to gracefully combine high components on a budget.

We’ve heard wonderful things about Badass Beard Care Beard Balm if you need something a bit more substantial for that untamed thicket on your face. This highly praised balm contains a significant amount of beeswax and can manage even the most tangled beard.

The Final Word

Maybe you believe we’ve been a little too enthusiastic in our appreciation of the Honest Amish. Simply said, this firm produces exceptional goods using high-quality, raw ingredients. While they are no longer as tiny as they once were, the Honest Amish have done an admirable job of sticking to their basic objective.

Furthermore, it’s difficult to identify which of its beard balms is superior than the others. Both are fantastic. We recommend using the regular Beard Balm if you have a short beard. Heavy Duty is the way to go if you have a big mane. You can’t lose either way.

By the way, if you’ve ever been confused about the difference between beard balm and beard butter, we’ve got you covered. Take a look at our answer to that query.

Ezoicthis advertisement should be reported

Watch This Video-

The “honest amish beard wax how to use” is a product that has been around for a while. It’s a popular choice among men who want to keep their beards looking good. The Honest Amish Beard Balm Vs Heavy Duty: Which Product Is Better?

Frequently Asked Questions

Does honest Amish beard balm help growth?

A: It is not a scientifically proven fact that honest Amish beard balm in any way helps growth of facial hair.

What is the difference between honest Amish Classic and Premium?

A: There is no difference between the two. The only noticeable differences are in color, leaf pattern and wood grain.

Which is better beard balm or oil?

A: To answer this question, it is important to understand what each of these products are. Beard balm is a moisturizing product that helps keep the beards skin healthy and prevents itching. On the other hand, oils can be used for styling purposes or as an aftershave treatment when applied directly on to the facial hair and scalp. This may cause some irritation if not properly mixed in with your current conditioner or shampoo.

Related Tags

  • honest amish review
  • honest amish beard review
  • what does honest amish beard oil do
  • honest amish beard balm recipe
  • honest amish unscented beard balm